Reading Notes: Genre edition
by Sunita
I read a bunch of books! I’m not sure how I managed that, since I’ve been grading and DUS-ing. But I discovered I’d finished three books in about a week: two mysteries and a romance/WF.

First up was The Janus Stone, the second installment in the Ruth Galloway series by Elly Griffiths. Ruth and Nelson go to Norwich, where bones have been discovered in the foundation of a large Victorian house that was most recently a children’s home. The property is now being turned into tiny but luxurious and expensive flats. The novel is set shortly after the previous one, and Ruth is experiencing the joys of first-trimester pregnancy, complete with morning sickness. Her born-again Christian parents are very upset that she is pregnant and refuses to name the father. At first she can hide her pregnancy but as the story progresses and time elapses that becomes more difficult.
I had mixed feelings about the pregnancy storyline at the end of the last book, but it is a good way of keeping Ruth and Nelson connected without turning them into an insta-couple. Nelson loves his wife and has no intention of breaking up his family, and Ruth doesn’t want him to. Nelson’s wife Michelle is an appealing character, and I’m not sure how this triangle is going to be resolved (by which I mean, Michelle is going to have to know at some point and what’s that going to do to their marriage and family?) but so far Griffiths has written it in a way that earns my trust.
As for the mystery itself, the bones turn out to be that of a child from decades ago rather than centuries. Are they those of the little girl who vanished from the home, or are they someone else’s? The story widens to include the former priest and nuns who ran the home, the past owners of the house, and others. Cathbad returns, and Ruth is in jeopardy once again. I didn’t see many of the twists although by the end the villain was fairly obvious. It took a while, though. And the Norfolk countryside was as well portrayed as before.

Next up was Death in Devon, the second installment of Ian Sansom’s County Guides mysteries. These are only nominally mysteries and mostly about Morley, Sefton, Miriam, and the people they encounter as they travel around England for Morley’s project. I found Miriam just as annoying as in the first book and unfortunately she’s around more, but Morley is definitely growing on me. The story is set at a minor public boys’ school in Devon, where Morley’s old friend is headmaster and has asked him to come and give a keynote address. A smashed car is found on the beach below the cliffs and solving this mystery (suicide or not) leads them to other weird happenings. There are plenty of characters and at times there is an air of real menace. And there are caves.
I’m very much liking the development of this series. This installment doesn’t get particularly high marks on Goodreads, but I think it’s because it’s not the 30s mystery readers are expecting, even though there is a death and other events to be solved and it is set in that period. There’s less backstory in this one, but Sefton’s Spain experiences are still part of the narrative and Morley is developing into more of a person and less of a construct. I hope the same happens with Miriam.

Finally, I started reading the new Sarah Morgan book, Family for Beginners and didn’t stop reading until I’d finished. OK, I took a couple of breaks for work and dinner and talking to TheH. But I was hooked and had to keep going until I found out what happened to everyone and everything. The central character, Flora meets Jack, a recent widower with two daughters, when he comes into the flower shop where she works. Flora is wonderful with plants and flowers and uncomfortable with people. She was raised by a stern, unloving aunt after her mother died when she was eight, and she’s alone in the world except for her friend and co-worker. She and Jack hit it off, but his daughters are a much harder sell, especially 17-year-old Izzy. Their mother, Becca, seems to have been practically perfect in every way, except of course she wasn’t.
Flora is shy and uncertain but also immensely empathetic. She’s made her way through life by pleasing people and putting her own needs last. Jack is loving and honorable and oblivious to many things, including how his daughters are really doing after their mother’s death. Plot twists throw them together into a makeshift family setup and when the action moves from New York City to the Lake District, various relationships and secrets emerge and demand resolutions. The romance between Jack and Flora is sweet and mostly hindered by external conflicts since they’re both such nice people, but those conflicts are believable. The plot developments reminded me of Rebecca on occasion, and the dead mother is even named Becca, so I wonder if there was some homage going on there. But Becca is not a monster, thank goodness; I can’t take any more Awful Other Women in my romances and women’s fiction reads.
If I have any quibbles with the book, it was that there was a lot of talking things out. A lot. I would have preferred more of the story to be about the settings, especially once they go to England. Morgan is so good at writing that context, and while what was there was great, I wanted the fell-walking scenes and the garden centre visit, not another kitchen-drama episode. But that really is a minor quibble, and I can see myself returning to this story and characters. I like stories where everyone is doing their best and is decent at heart and where the conflicts are the normal everyday type, which doesn’t make them easier to resolve or trivial, just familiar. Even the fabulous boathouse (oh, of course it’s an homage to Rebecca!) is rented out most of the year for additional income. If you’re a Morgan fan you’ll recognize the settings and some of the character types, and the dog, but that won’t make them less enjoyable.
I can’t believe I didn’t spot the Rebecca references! Now I have to read it again. I’m glad you enjoyed it too.
LikeLike
Inorite? I noticed a few as I was reading, but they didn’t really register until I was writing up this post. I avoid reviews and discussions about books I know I’m going to read until after I’m done, so I had no idea what the book was about.
LikeLike
I just listened to the most recent in Griffiths’ other series (set in mid-20th c Brighton). It was a bit disappointing because the best thing about the series for me was the setting in the waning days of vaudeville, and this one jumped forward 10 years to the 60s. Battle of mods and rockers was not as interesting (or as big a part of the story as the vaudeville/magic stuff had been).
Your comments on Janus Stone made me think about how much Griffiths uses triangles in both series. A LOT. And some of them are kind of endlessly strung out and annoying. I sometimes felt that way about the basic triangle at the center of the Ruth Galloway series and the changes she rings on it, but for the most part it’s interesting and unexpected and she managed to make me keep liking all the characters and think they were doing their best, which is a challenge with this kind of plot. (I especially like the way Michelle is never quite a dumb blonde foil for Ruth, even though that stereotype sometimes looms).
I somehow got to be 2nd in line for the Murderbot novel from the library! And downloaded it yesterday! Now I must give it the reading attention it deserves.
LikeLike
I really don’t like triangles, especially in mystery series. I stopped reading the Julia Spencer Fleming series because the relationship one really put me off. I’m OK with this one because everyone is acting like adults so far, and I’m interested to see how things develop and change. Ruth deserves a proper partner if she wants one, and I agree about Michelle.
I put the Murderbot novel on hold for TheH and it unexpectedly came in today! The library must have bought more copies. So he’s all set and I’m going to see if I can get through the novellas in time to read it too. It’s a 21-day loan, so it’s just possible. Especially now that my grading is done!
LikeLike
I just finished the new Murderbot and it was So Good! It was a little slow in the beginning, but once I got into it I didn’t want it to end.
LikeLike
I reread the first installment yesterday and loved it. When I first read it I had trouble keeping track of the people and what was going on, but it made total sense this time. I’m trying not to guzzle the 4 novellas at once, so that I can enjoy the experience and remember them better.
LikeLike
Hmm, that Sarah Morgan sounds interesting. I have stayed away mostly because I tired one of her harlequins and it didn’t do much for me (I can’t even remember the title). But I do better with bigger books, and the plot you described sounds has potential.
LikeLike
I would definitely try the excerpt and see what you think. It’s a good introduction to the characters.
LikeLike
I’ve got the new Sarah Morgan on hold! Love what you said about it and can’t wait to try it!
LikeLike
I think you’ll enjoy it. Morgan is so good at writing heroines shy, or insecure, but not doormat heroines.
LikeLike
Erm, I mean read it!
LikeLike
🙂
LikeLike